Day 26: MYTH: If my dog behaves better for someone else, I must be the problem

81%

MYTH: “My dog is better with someone else, so I must be the problem.”

Your dog walker takes your dog out and says they were absolutely fine.
Your partner walks them and they don’t react half as much.
Your trainer takes the lead and suddenly your dog looks like a different animal.

And immediately you think:

“It must be me.”

“They’re picking up on my anxiety.”
“They don’t respect me.”
“I’m making them reactive.”

But… there’s another possibility that doesn’t get talked about nearly enough.

Masking.

When a dog is with somebody unfamiliar, or even just somebody they have a very different relationship with, they may not behave in exactly the same way they do with you.

A new person is new information, so your dog doesn’t necessarily know what this person will do.

They don’t know how they’ll respond.
They don’t have the same history with them.
They don’t have hundreds or thousands of previous experiences together telling them what normally happens next.

And, that can change behaviour.

Some dogs become quieter.
More inhibited.
More cautious.
They watch more.
They offer less.

They may even suppress behaviours we’d normally see when they’re with someone they know incredibly well.

From the outside, that can very quickly look like:

“Wow. They’re so much better for them.”

But… less behaviour doesn’t automatically mean the dog feels better.

Sometimes it simply means we’re seeing less of what they’re feeling.

Think about yourself.

You probably don’t behave exactly the same way with a stranger as you do with somebody you completely trust.

You’re more likely to monitor yourself and them.

Hold things back.
Work out the social rules.
Figure out who this person is before you completely relax around them.

Dogs can change their behaviour depending on social context too.

And, sometimes the person they feel safest with is also the person who gets to see the biggest expression of behaviour.

That doesn’t mean we should dismiss every difference as masking, but sometimes another handler genuinely is doing something differently.

Whether thats their timing, lead handling, movement, reinforcement placements, expectations or decision-making might all be different and therefore, change the situation.

So, if you’ve thought or experienced any of the above, I don’t want you automatically jumping from:

“My dog behaves differently with them”

to:

“Therefore I am causing my dog’s behaviour.”

Instead, get curious.

Does your dog actually look more relaxed with that person?

Or are they simply quieter?

More watchful?
More inhibited?
Less expressive?

Because, quiet and comfortable aren’t necessarily the same thing.

So, if you’ve ever been told:

“They’re absolutely fine when you’re not here…”

Don’t immediately hear:

“You’re the problem.”

Ask a much better question:

“Why does my dog’s behaviour change depending on who they’re with?”

Because that answer can tell us far more about your dog than blame ever will.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *